New York Red Bulls's goals were scored by Holgersson (13'), Cooper (27', 88') and Henry (90') and Toronto FC's goalscorer was Johnson (6'). New York Red Bulls's starting line-up was Robles, Pearce, Holgersson, Conde, Barklage, Cahill, McCarty, Lindpere, Sam, Henry and Cooper while Toronto FC lined up with Hall, O'Dea, Eckersley, Morgan, Hall, Dunfield, Maund, Amarikwa, Lambe, Johnson and Silva.

Chicago Fire's goalscorers were Macdonald (65', 78'). New York Red Bulls's starting line-up was Robles, Pearce, Holgersson, Conde, Barklage, Cahill, McCarty, Lindpere, Gunnar Solli, Henry and Cooper while Chicago Fire lined up with Johnson, Friedrich, Berry, Segares, Anibaba, Pause, Paladini, Fernández, Nyarko, Macdonald and Rolfe.

New York Red Bulls 0 - 0 Sporting Kansas City

Philadelphia Union 0 - 3 New York Red Bulls

York City 1 - 1 AFC Wimbledon

New York Red Bulls 0 - 1 DC United

DC United 1 - 1 New York Red Bulls

AFC Wimbledon beat York City in extra time to set up a potential tie with bitter rivals MK Dons in the next round.

Portland Timbers 3-3 New York Red Bulls

San Jose Earthquakes 2-1 New York Red Bulls